Is Your Homeowners Insurance Requiring a Roof Replacement? Here’s What You Need to Know

Why Insurance Companies Require a New Roof

Insurance companies view your roof as a key factor in determining your home’s risk level. A worn-out roof increases the chances of costly claims due to water damage, structural issues, and mold growth. While they cannot legally force you to replace your roof, they can refuse to renew your policy or provide full coverage unless your roof is in acceptable condition.

Key Reasons Insurers May Require a Roof Replacement:

• Age of the Roof: If your roof is over 15-20 years old, many insurance companies will classify it as too risky to cover fully. Some insurers have even stricter policies, requiring replacement for roofs older than 7 years.
• Roof Condition: Signs of wear such as missing shingles, leaks, sagging, or visible damage can trigger a demand for replacement.
• Claims History: If you’ve made multiple roof-related claims in the past, your insurer may require a replacement to continue coverage.
• Structural Concerns: Insurance providers assume that older roofs may have hidden issues, such as compromised decking or underlying water damage, even if no leaks are immediately visible.

What If You Disagree with Your Insurance Company?

If your insurer has determined that your roof needs to be replaced, you do have options:

1. Review Your Policy

Carefully check your homeowner’s insurance policy to understand the exact requirements and exclusions related to roofing. Some policies will cover a full replacement, while others only offer actual cash value (ACV), meaning you’ll receive compensation based on the depreciated value of your roof.

2. Get a Professional Roof Inspection

Before committing to a full replacement, consider hiring a licensed roofing contractor to conduct an independent inspection. If their assessment contradicts your insurance company’s findings, you may have grounds to negotiate or appeal the decision.

3. Negotiate with Your Insurance Provider

Discuss options with your insurance agent. If your roof has minor issues that can be fixed with repairs rather than a full replacement, ask if they would accept proof of repairs to maintain coverage.

4. Shop for a New Insurance Provider

If your current insurer is being overly strict, you may find a different provider with more lenient policies. However, keep in mind that many companies follow industry-wide standards regarding roof age and condition.

Will Insurance Cover the Cost of a New Roof?

This depends on the reason for replacement and your policy terms.

• Covered Situations: If your roof has been damaged due to an event covered by your insurance (such as hail, windstorms, or fire), your policy may cover the full replacement cost.
• Denied Coverage: If your roof is being flagged simply because of its age or gradual wear and tear, your insurer may not pay for the replacement.
• Partial Coverage: Some insurers only pay the depreciated value of an older roof, leaving homeowners to cover the rest of the cost out of pocket.

What to Do If Your Roof Needs Replacement

If you decide to move forward with a roof replacement, follow these steps:

1. Get Multiple Quotes: Compare estimates from reputable roofing contractors.
2. Ask About Financing Options: If insurance won’t cover the cost, consider financing plans or home improvement loans.
3. Schedule Your Roof Replacement Quickly: If your insurance company has given you a deadline, don’t delay. Failure to replace your roof in time could lead to policy non-renewal.
4. Keep All Documentation: Save receipts, inspection reports, and communication with your insurance company in case you need to appeal or switch providers in the future.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Wait Until It’s Too Late

If your homeowner’s insurance company is requiring a roof replacement, it’s important to act quickly. A failing roof isn’t just a risk to your insurance policy—it could lead to severe damage to your home. By being proactive and working with a trusted roofing professional, you can ensure your home remains protected and covered.

At Velocity Roofing, we specialize in helping homeowners navigate insurance-mandated roof replacements. Our team provides expert inspections, detailed estimates, and quality roofing solutions to keep your home safe.

Need a Roof Inspection? Contact Velocity Roofing Today!

‍